Questioning Reborn 2.0

Any pictures or a possible showcase?

3 minutes ago, Apacheactual21 said:

Any pictures or a possible showcase?

Possibly in the future, my main goal was to just finally get it out, its been in the works for months now and held back.

But showcases and screenshots wont be able to show off everything. Always best, in my opinion and personal practices, to just see what your getting. 

though I will certainly be submitting a request to some guys I know for showcases, BlueLineVibes and SST specifically.

Just now, Officer034 said:

Possibly in the future, my main goal was to just finally get it out, its been in the works for months now and held back.

But showcases and screenshots wont be able to show off everything. Always best, in my opinion and personal practices, to just see what your getting. 

though I will certainly be submitting a request to some guys I know for showcases, BlueLineVibes and SST specifically.

Sounds good to me! I was just curious brother, love your search items reborn so I am sure this as well will be great!

loving it i'm pretty sure you will add most of the things are missing, but have few in mind

1- one is arrest warrant  questions detailed  like it starts as general  question are you aware of the arrest warrent the if the ped answer no what for, then we can add detials of the kind of warrent they have as an answer. ex" well my computer say you or are wanted for "X" then even can build up more questions of that and answers to RP more

2- invistigation questions little bit quuestion here and there. for example sometimes Cars that  gets flagged by the ALPR system while parked for no registration or anything, and there is like 1-2 peds next to it i wish to have questions about if they knows whose car is this do they know the car owner etc...

3- i would also love to see more of details type of question than just general answers like they said no for something i can answer well, i found this "X' in your car or like when giving tickets for speeding i can see i was going to give you a warning but you'be been doing this all the time something like that  lol... i'm sorry if i'm just speaking nonsense in here, but hopefully you get my feedback just more RP keep up the good work tho, cant wait for future updates :)

10 hours ago, legendzeox said:

loving it i'm pretty sure you will add most of the things are missing, but have few in mind

 

1- one is arrest warrant  questions detailed  like it starts as general  question are you aware of the arrest warrent the if the ped answer no what for, then we can add detials of the kind of warrent they have as an answer. ex" well my computer say you or are wanted for "X" then even can build up more questions of that and answers to RP more

 

2- invistigation questions little bit quuestion here and there. for example sometimes Cars that  gets flagged by the ALPR system while parked for no registration or anything, and there is like 1-2 peds next to it i wish to have questions about if they knows whose car is this do they know the car owner etc...

 

3- i would also love to see more of details type of question than just general answers like they said no for something i can answer well, i found this "X' in your car or like when giving tickets for speeding i can see i was going to give you a warning but you'be been doing this all the time something like that  lol... i'm sorry if i'm just speaking nonsense in here, but hopefully you get my feedback just more RP keep up the good work tho, cant wait for future updates 🙂

 

 

Problem with some of these additions is just the crappy way STP handles interactions with just random chances. Plus keeping questioning from being overly cluttered, that's an issue I tend to have with other questioning xmls I've tried before, it gets overly cluttered when you try to add too much. However some of these are good ideas. Just idk how to properly implement them, especially the "asking who's car this is" question just cause, how would it go from there especially given random chance answers? Ya know? STP doesn't assign vehicles to nearby peds usually. Wish there was a chance for it though.

To add on, responding to their no with finding something does already exist? It's in the search questions. I'm a bit confused by that. Adding the option for every type of charge for "you've done this too much" is damn near impossible however I like the idea of telling them you are charging them because they have done it multiple times.

Edited August 26, 20241 yr by Officer034

How to translate questions into Russian?

9 hours ago, gorky99 said:

How to translate questions into Russian?

Would have to manually run it through Google translate or have a native Russian speaker make a translation pack. I know someone did it for Search Items Reborn I might reach out to them.

thank you very much, if possible, you may be able to leave a link to download the translation) Good luck bro :)

One thing that is missing that I have seen specifically is fights. General fights to domestic disputes. So far as your CVE stuff, if you need some guidance as to questions and the like, I am prior SO and current CDL driver. Can give some basic rundowns of how CVE inspections / CMV interactions in general go, if youre interested when you get to that point let me know. 

8 hours ago, batwingsix said:

One thing that is missing that I have seen specifically is fights. General fights to domestic disputes. So far as your CVE stuff, if you need some guidance as to questions and the like, I am prior SO and current CDL driver. Can give some basic rundowns of how CVE inspections / CMV interactions in general go, if youre interested when you get to that point let me know. 

Would love to work with ya, and roadmap includes domestics. General fights are good, might be added.

On 8/28/2024 at 9:55 PM, batwingsix said:

One thing that is missing that I have seen specifically is fights. General fights to domestic disputes. So far as your CVE stuff, if you need some guidance as to questions and the like, I am prior SO and current CDL driver. Can give some basic rundowns of how CVE inspections / CMV interactions in general go, if youre interested when you get to that point let me know. 

Hey, newest version I took your advice and added fights, and next version is either going to be Domestic or CVE! Thank you so much for your input, its been a valuable tool for QR! Glad to have some help!

I have always been big fan of your work its what got me into making stuff for bejoijos plugins thanks again for all you do in lspdfr community

Took a gamble on this before the video was released. And i waited a bit, played around with it. I can truly say AMAZING. Keep up the great work! 

44 minutes ago, Apacheactual21 said:

Took a gamble on this before the video was released. And i waited a bit, played around with it. I can truly say AMAZING. Keep up the great work! 

Thanks a ton! If you havent, should check out Search Items Reborn. Similar if not better quality. 

Would be nice to add questions for someone at proximity of a vehicle reported stolen and questions for robberies, maybe burglaries and i think the homicide questions would be good to add. And also sometimes i can't tell if a suspect is refusing an order for example when i request an ID, would be nice to add a word "refusing" and i think suspect should be more often cooperative, i find it pretty common of suspects being hostile or uncooperative. And lastly would be also nice to add that a vehicle is stolen with the VIN Check (For you content "Charge Reborn" there no VIN tampering charges ).

Edited September 3, 20241 yr by Mathox

1 hour ago, Mathox said:

Would be nice to add questions for someone at proximity of a vehicle reported stolen and questions for robberies, maybe burglaries and i think the homicide questions would be good to add. And also sometimes i can't tell if a suspect is refusing an order for example when i request an ID, would be nice to add a word "refusing" and i think suspect should be more often cooperative, i find it pretty common of suspects being hostile or uncooperative. And lastly would be also nice to add that a vehicle is stolen with the VIN Check (For you content "Charge Reborn" there no VIN tampering charges ).

Lots of good ideas, and however the liklihood of a suspect being uncooperative is unfortunately uncontrollable with how STP handles questions. I cant assign any to be more common other than just repeating it in the XML. Over 1/3 of questions are fully cooperative, 1/3 are semi cooperative or avoidant and another 1/3 fully uncooperative. Refusal additions might happen but are unlikely. VIN checks were recently added to the traffic stop questions and might come to the on foot soon. Thanks for the input.

On 9/2/2024 at 10:39 AM, Officer034 said:

Thanks a ton! If you havent, should check out Search Items Reborn. Similar if not better quality. 

Already have it. One of the first mods I installed! 

On 9/2/2024 at 8:57 PM, Officer034 said:

Lots of good ideas, and however the liklihood of a suspect being uncooperative is unfortunately uncontrollable with how STP handles questions. I cant assign any to be more common other than just repeating it in the XML. Over 1/3 of questions are fully cooperative, 1/3 are semi cooperative or avoidant and another 1/3 fully uncooperative. Refusal additions might happen but are unlikely. VIN checks were recently added to the traffic stop questions and might come to the on foot soon. Thanks for the input.

Maybe if you add more positive anwser, this will increase the chance of suspect being nice and cooperative.

SO HAPPY to see this released, been using the same Q&A System for years now, been waiting for a new one to come along that could compete! Excited to try this.

12 hours ago, Mathox said:

Maybe if you add more positive anwser, this will increase the chance of suspect being nice and cooperative.

It will, but its just how I have it set up, something a certain project going by PR might be fixing, that I am working very closely with. 

Hey, man, was looking forward to this for a while and I'm loving it so far! Just a quick note though, I noticed in one section there is a misspelling of "assess" as "asses" which, while unintentionally kinda funny, is probably not something you probably want to keep. Hope this helps!

10 hours ago, amenbrother said:

Hey, man, was looking forward to this for a while and I'm loving it so far! Just a quick note though, I noticed in one section there is a misspelling of "assess" as "asses" which, while unintentionally kinda funny, is probably not something you probably want to keep. Hope this helps!

Yeahhh that part I wrote half asleep, expect it fixed in the next update.

Consider adding more sovereign citizen (SC) responses. I usually go into these and add a bunch of "I'm not driving, I'm traveling." and "Get me your supervisor" and "No, I'm not" (when responding to being informed they're under arrest) and "Am I being detained?" when you just say "hi." "Am I being detained; am I free to go?" is a great response for any greeting or question as well.

This could be its own section - where if you get an SC response you can go to a Q&A section group to roleplay a whole SC interaction.

Edited September 8, 20241 yr by SlimInAZ

38 minutes ago, SlimInAZ said:

Consider adding more sovereign citizen (SC) responses. I usually go into these and add a bunch of "I'm not driving, I'm traveling." and "Get me your supervisor" and "No, I'm not" (when responding to being informed they're under arrest) and "Am I being detained?" when you just say "hi." "Am I being detained; am I free to go?" is a great response for any greeting or question as well.

This could be its own section - where if you get an SC response you can go to a Q&A section group to roleplay a whole SC interaction.

While I love the idea, it just feels disjointed when you think about the way that STP handles questioning. Its something I plan to include in an upcoming remake of QR for Policing Redefined as it will have parameters for suspect behavior. But with the random nature of STP, having a sovereign citizen remain consistent in questions is impossible, thus to me just feels like wasted time. I just really dont want to add a WHOLE menu for SC based interactions, it will throw off the current organization, and again with how STP handles questioning, and the way I am doing the questions (Utilizing ChatGPT for answers) makes doing that petty difficult.

I appreciate the interaction and its not being thrown out as a whole, but I do have to see what I can do to work around STP's questioning or wait for PR to finally release and include suspect behavior parameters.

Okay, after using this for some time, I have some things to say.

First off, I think this Mod is fantastic and holds A LOT of potential as a new main Q&A Source, here are a few things that I have noticed:

1. The Answers sometimes feel REALLY "soulless" for lack of a better term, I am well aware the answers are AI Generated, but a good portion of the time it really feels like the interaction is almost robotic in a sense because a good chunk of the responses are something like "I'm sorry, I won't do that again." I hardly ever encounter people who have that mentality in real life (I am NOT a Police Officer, I work in the Private Sector as Security and Close Protection) my main point of this critique is to say it would be really nice if you added varying responses to each Question, similar to what another mod did where it had different Mood Ranges for each question. Yes this would take a lot of time and be extremely tedious, but as of right now I feel like that is the current thing that feels like it is missing. 

2. This is a very Minor one following my first point, but I would really like to see more Questions added to the "Passenger Traffic Stop" section. Like "who does ___ belong to?" or "The Car belongs to you, why aren't you driving it?" those sorts of questions would be nice to have. 

All in all, so far, its pretty freakin awesome, in my opinion, some more variety in the Moods and Tones of the Answers, and some additional Questions would make this mod a perfect choice for the Q&A portion of STP. Great work so far!